Veteran actor Troy Baker, known for iconic roles like Joel Miller in The Last of Us, recently urged creatives not to “demonize” artificial intelligence, asserting that while AI can generate content, it “cannot create art.” Speaking to The Game Business, as reported by GamesIndustry.biz, Baker highlighted that genuine art inherently requires human experience and artists, a crucial distinction often overlooked in the ongoing debate around Troy Baker AI art discussions.
The rise of AI tools across various creative sectors, from writing to visual arts and voice acting, has sparked widespread apprehension. Many industry professionals fear job displacement and the devaluation of human skill. Baker, a prominent figure in the gaming world, acknowledges these concerns, particularly among “people in the business of content,” yet offers a more nuanced perspective on AI’s long-term impact on creativity and the arts.
He points out that AI’s capabilities, such as generating historically accurate visuals of events like the Gettysburg Address in seconds, are undeniable. However, he differentiates this high-fidelity content creation from the profound act of art-making, which he believes remains an exclusively human endeavor. This distinction forms the core of his argument against outright rejection of the technology.
The irreplaceable human element in art
Baker firmly states that a fundamental premise of art-making is its reliance on artists. “People go, ‘look what AI can do’. It’s like, ‘yeah, okay. I see what it’s capable of doing. It doesn’t matter’,” he elaborated. This perspective underscores that while AI can mimic styles or generate vast amounts of data-driven content, it lacks the subjective, emotional, and experiential depth that defines human artistic expression. The connection between creator and audience, forged through shared humanity, is central.
The veteran actor contends that art requires an intrinsic understanding of the human condition, something machines cannot replicate. A recent report by the World Economic Forum on AI’s impact on creative industries supports the idea that while AI may automate routine tasks, critical thinking, creativity, and emotional intelligence remain uniquely human strengths. Baker’s message encourages creatives to recognize this inherent value rather than simply fearing the new technology.
AI as a catalyst for authenticity
Paradoxically, Baker suggests that the burgeoning AI industry will actually “drive people to the authentic.” He envisions a future where the abundance of AI-generated content will heighten appreciation for live performances, physical books, and direct, first-hand experiences. “What I see happening is that this birth of AI…is actually going to drive people to the authentic,” he stated, referring to it as a “revolution.”
This viewpoint aligns with observations in other industries where automation has sometimes led to a renewed demand for artisan goods or personalized services. As AI democratizes content creation, the unique touch of human creativity could become even more valuable and sought after. A Harvard Business Review article explored how AI tools might shift the focus of human creatives towards higher-level conceptualization and unique artistic vision, rather than rote execution.
Troy Baker’s call to view AI not as a demon but as a distinct tool offers a vital perspective for creatives navigating this evolving landscape. By understanding AI’s limitations in truly creating art, and recognizing its potential to elevate the demand for authentic human expression, artists and industries alike can find ways to adapt and even thrive. The challenge lies in harnessing AI’s capabilities for content, while fiercely safeguarding the irreplaceable heart of human artistry and experience.
